In multiple preregistration clinical trials, obeticholic acid was found to decrease serum enzyme elevations in a high proportion of patients with different liver diseases. Instances of paradoxical worsening of liver disease or further increases in serum ALT or AST were not reported. However, the product label for obeticholic acid includes warnings that serious liver related adverse events occurred more commonly with active therapy than with placebo treatment. In a pooled analysis of 3 placebo controlled trials in patients with primary biliary cholangitis, liver related adverse events were 5.2 per 100 patient exposure years with 10 mg and 2.4 with placebo. Even higher rates occurred with higher doses of obeticholic acid: 19.8 per 100 patient years for 25 mg daily and 54.5 for 50 mg daily. The clinical features, timing of onset, pattern of enzyme elevations and course of these events were not described in detail. Within a little over a year after approval of obeticholic acid as therapy for primary biliary cholangitis, the FDA published a warning letter stating that they had received notification of 19 deaths and 11 cases of severe liver injury in patients taking obeticholic acid, most but not all of whom had preexisting cirrhosis (Case 1). More recently, severe instances of hepatic decompensation have been reported in patients with both primary biliary cholangitis as well as primary sclerosing cholangitis, two similar chronic cholestatic liver diseases.
In patients with normal alkaline phosphatase levels, obeticholic therapy is associated with slight elevations in alkaline phosphatase, but without accompanying changes in serum aminotransferase levels, GGT or bilirubin, suggesting that the increases are due to alkaline phosphatase from other sources (bone, gastrointestinal tract). Therapy with OCA has been associated with development of pruritus in up to one-third of patients, but the appearance or worsening of itching is not usually associated with worsening of the underlying liver disease or increase in bilirubin or bile acid levels (other than OCA). Thus, obeticholic acid has apparent beneficial effects on liver test abnormalities, but has been linked to rare instances of worsening liver disease which may have clinical significance in patients with preexisting cirrhosis, particularly with use of higher doses of OCA.
Likelihood score: B (a rare but potentially severe cause of clinically apparent liver injury occurring mostly in patients with preexisting cirrhosis).