Methods for the detection of reactive intermediates such as transient radicals are important in organic chemistry, polymer chemistry, biology or medicine. Along these lines we recently reported that 1,5-diphenyl-6-oxo verdazyl radicals can be used as fluorescent spin sensors. In situ generated C-centered radicals are efficiently trapped by the verdazyls, which in turn undergo transformation from a paramagnetic non-fluorescent state to a diamagnetic fluorescent state. Whereas the N-phenyl substituent in the spin probes is of high importance for obtaining profluorescent behavior, the effect of the C(3)-substituent has not been investigated to date. We herein present the synthesis and characterization of various 1,5-diphenyl-6-oxo-verdazyl radicals bearing differently hybridized C-substituents at the C(3) position. Steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy in solution and in the solid state along with time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations reveal that a C(3)-aryl substituent is crucial for obtaining fluorescence after spin trapping. In addition, it is shown that the emission wavelength of the C(3)-aryl substituted verdazyl derivatives can be tuned by selective destabilization of the HOMO and the LUMO.