Easy as pie: Expedientaccess to aryl‐substituted benzofulvenes is described. α‐Hydroxyallenes 1 that bear two aryl groups at C1 (red circle) are directly transformed into these products at roomtemperature by using silver triflate as a catalyst or Brønsted acids. The transformation involves dealkoxylation and subsequent 4π electrocyclization (Nazarov reaction).