A copper-catalyzed [2 + 3] formal cyclization reaction between α-hydroxyl ketones and arylacetonitriles has been developed. The reaction outcome was ultimately dependent on the structure of the α-hydroxy ketones employed. Tertiary α-hydroxy ketones gave 3,4,5,5-tetrasubstituted butenolides as the sole products, while secondary α-hydroxy ketones furnished 2,4,5-trisubstituted oxazoles selectively. This